A higher risk rating in retail snow removal increases the potential for costly slip and fall injuries. Learn how effective risk management and robust Business Interruption insurance protect you from lost income and other potential risks.
The winter season brings lucrative opportunities for snow removal contractors, but it also brings a specialized and significant risk profile. For commercial snow removal businesses in Toronto and across Canada, understanding the difference between serving a bustling commercial client and managing a quiet residential portfolio is imperative.
Your client type directly impacts your exposure to liability, the complexity of your business operations, and ultimately, your insurance needs and costs.
The risk rating for these two site types changes your overall risk on business and how you can ensure your coverage options are up to the challenge. Let’s dive deeper below.
The Core Difference: Risk Exposure and Incident Rates
Snow triples the risk of slip-and-fall accidents. When combined with factors like foot traffic, operating hours, lighting, and complexity, fundamentally separate the hazards of retail plazas from residential sites, the potential for liability claims and injuries drastically increases further. That's why maintaining a property safe from ice and snow is a major concern for contractors.
Retail Plazas: A High-Exposure Classification
Retail plazas, shopping centres, and commercial properties present a high-exposure environment. The higher volume of activity leads to a higher premium calculation by your insurance company.
- Footfall: High foot traffic significantly drives the overall risk. A busy retail walkway or parking lot can see thousands of customers daily. More people on the business premises means an exponentially higher chance of a fall incident, translating to a greater risk rating for insurers. This creates a high probability of a claim.
- The Cost of Failure: Property owners of commercial sites demand prompt, reliable service. Failure to clear snow or effectively salt surfaces can quickly lead to a catastrophic slip and fall accident and injuries such as broken bones, head trauma, or long-term disability.
- Incident Rates: Claims arising from slippery surfaces are more frequent and costly in a retail environment. A slip and fall injury on commercial property is almost always litigious, and the property owners (and by extension, the contractor) can be held liable for damages.
Learn more: Why Is Snow Removal a High-Risk Industry?
Image Source: Pexels
Residential Sites: A Lower Risk Profile
Residential driveways and small complexes present a manageable, lower-volume risk profile, often resulting in a low potential for claims.
- Low Footfall: Traffic is significantly lower, reducing the statistical likelihood of a slip and fall accident.
- Reduced Liability: While the risk of liability remains, residential jobs tend to result in fewer high-value claims than retail sites, reducing the potential for major financial loss.
The Role of Effective Risk Management
Contractors must implement strategies to minimize the likelihood of slip and fall injuries and their overall risk score. Strict compliance with local bylaws and industry safety standards is essential to keep every property safe.
- A proper risk assessment starts with identifying exposure factors, such as poor drainage, inadequate lighting, or insufficient salting.
Using a risk matrix helps determine the probability and severity of potential incidents. For example, a thorough site inspection helps identify uneven surfaces that could lead to a slip-and-fall accident.
Essential Coverage: Why Income Protection is Critical
Covered incidents like fire, equipment failure, or natural disasters can prevent your business operations from continuing and put a dent in your business income. Here’s where additional coverages in your snow plowing insurance policy come into play.
Even when operations are temporarily halted, a robust, properly structured and customized policy helps:
- maintain cash during shutdowns
- meet contractual insurance requirements
- protect your long-term client relationships.
Here are additional coverages your snow plowing insurance policy should include for complete protection:
- Commercial General Liability: This is the foundation, protecting you from financial losses resulting from third-party bodily injury (like slip and fall accidents) or property damage caused by your operations.
- Umbrella Liability: If you serve commercial contracts like shopping centres, an umbrella policy provides an extra layer of protection, activating when the limits on your CGL policy are exhausted. This coverage is vital when dealing with high-risk ratings and the potential for multi-million-dollar slip-and-fall injury claims.
- Commercial Property: Business Interruption coverage is typically found as an endorsement within a comprehensive commercial property insurance policy. This policy protects your physical assets, like your office or storage facility, against a covered peril.
- Business Interruption: Lost income coverage helps you recover and ensures you can meet financial obligations like loan payments and other operating expenses. Specifically, the policy covers operating expenses such as payroll and rent for your business premises.
Comparison of Insurance Requirements by Site Type
|
Requirement |
Retail Plaza (High Risk) |
Residential Site (Low Risk) |
|
Typical CGL Limit |
$5M – $10M+ |
$1M – $2M |
|
Primary Risk Factors |
High footfall, 24/7 access, complex lighting |
Low traffic, predictable hours, simple layouts |
|
Umbrella Insurance |
Highly recommended/Mandatory |
Often optional |
|
Business Interruption |
Essential for high-retainer firms |
Recommended for full-time operators |
|
Compliance Needs |
Strict logbooks and GPS tracking |
Basic service records |
Learn more: How to Get Snow Removal Insurance
FAQs About Liability of Snow Removal
The increase in customer foot traffic elevates your company's potential for high-value injury lawsuits, requiring higher limits and different coverage options, while also impacting your insurer's categorization.
If the equipment breakdown is a covered loss under your property policy, business interruption insurance can replace the business income you lose while your equipment is being repaired.
Immediately follow your established procedure: identify the scene, document weather conditions with photos, and collect witness information to support your eventual insurance claim.
Yes, your standard commercial vehicle policy must have the appropriate endorsements to cover specialized plowing equipment and the unique liabilities of on-site retail and residential snow removal work.
Key Takeaways
- Risk Rating: Commercial properties require higher insurance limits due to increased liability exposure.
- Fall Accidents: Busy retail lots increase the risk of patron injury and litigation.
- Risk Management: Compliance with safety standards and documenting protocols protects contractors from negligence claims.
- Business Interruption: Safeguards income and covers expenses during unexpected business interruptions.
- Financial Loss Protection: A firm liability policy protects against significant lawsuit losses.
If you’re ready to move beyond residential snow removal contracts and handle the increased business exposure presented by high-value commercial and retail contracts, it’s time to contact the experts at KASE Insurance to structure an insurance program that matches the scale of your ambition. Reach out today to get a free quote.